Article
The American Journal of Psychoanalysis (2008) 68, 257–275. doi:10.1057/ajp.2008.22
Concern and Empathy: Two Concepts or One?
Rami Tolmacz1
Correspondence: Rami Tolmacz, Ph.D., Department of Psychology, Bar-Ilan University, 52900 Ramat Gan, Israel. e-mail: tolmacr@mail.biu.ac.il
1Ph.D is a faculty member in the clinical psychology program of the Bar-Ilan University Department of Psychology, as well as a practicing clinical psychologist and supervisor.
Abstract
For years, concern was treated as a marginal concept in psychoanalytic thought. Awareness of its importance increased due to the rise of object-relations theories: Suttie's description of the inborn impulse to give, attachment theory and the behavioral system of caregiving, and of course the emphasis on concern in the theoretical thinking of Winnicott, who even wanted to change the Kleinian term depressive position to stage of concern. However, the centrality that empathy took on with the appearance of self psychology made it seem unnecessary to pay separate attention to concern. The relational approach sheds new light on the concept of concern. This paper proposes distinguishing between empathy and concern as two different mental functions that affect each other. Under normal conditions they are intertwined and produce the unique way in which the individual relates to others.
Keywords:
concern, empathy, object-relations, intersubjectivity
MORE ARTICLES LIKE THIS
These links to content published by Palgrave Macmillan are automatically generated.
RESEARCH
Concern and Empathy: Two Concepts or One?The American Journal of Psychoanalysis Article
Technical Considerations in the Psychotherapy of Traumatized Individuals: A Psychoanalytic PerspectiveThe American Journal of Psychoanalysis Article
Friendship, socialization, and the immigrant experiencePsychoanalysis, Culture & Society Original Article
Figuration of the Real as an Intersubjective Process: Discussion of Lewis Kirshner's PaperThe American Journal of Psychoanalysis Article
The Man Who Could Not Cry and the Psychoanalyst Who Could: Mutual Healing in the Maternal Transference/CountertransferenceThe American Journal of Psychoanalysis Article
See all 52 matches for Research
