Higher Education Policy

TABLE 1

FROM:

Learning to Live with League Tables and Ranking: The Experience of Institutional Leaders

Ellen Hazelkorn

BACK TO ARTICLE

Table 1. Perception of how LTRS impact on key stakeholders

  Examples
Benefactors/Sponsorshipsfilled circle 'It totally depends on the rank'
filled circle 'I think all will tend to go for the best in the rank'
filled circle 'They feel reassured supporting us'
filled circle 'To date only universities have benefitted'
filled circle 'Benefactors don't want to be associated with losers, they want their image to be associated with winners only'
  
Collaborators/Partnersfilled circle 'Willingness to join common programme'
filled circle 'Good for reputation at international level'
  
Current/Future Facultyfilled circle 'Increases awareness about the importance of publishing high quality research'
filled circle 'Easier to induce improvement with the department head whose rankings are declining'
filled circle 'Stimulus to compare research output and teaching quality'
filled circle 'Recruitment will be easier because of good reputation'
filled circle 'Make standards for appointment/promotion more clear and transparent'
  
Employersfilled circle 'Degree holders from universities with good reputation have better chances to get a job (and vice versa)'
filled circle 'Employers get the signal of quality'
filled circle 'They feel reassured. Those not open to us become more receptive'
  
Governmentfilled circle 'Repetition of negative reputation'
filled circle 'Accreditation is easier'
filled circle 'Less pretext for obstacles, more doors opened'
filled circle 'May believe simplistic picture'
filled circle 'Local government is inclined to spend additional money for an excellent university'
  
Students/Parentsfilled circle 'More students are willing to come to the campus'
filled circle 'High profile students usually apply to high profile universities'
filled circle 'Particularly in the international market where status and prestige are considered in decision-making...'
filled circle 'Pride (actively shown e.g. in public forums)'
filled circle 'Advise their children to go to highly ranked universities'

  Source: Adapted from Hazelkorn (2007).

BACK TO ARTICLE