Abstract
This article seeks to systematise and advance the theoretical debate on the causes and conditions for the privatisation of security. Drawing on previous research on private military and security companies (PMSCs) and theories from International Relations and Comparative Politics, it reconstructs functionalist, political-instrumentalist and ideationist explanations for why and under what conditions even ‘strong’ and democratic Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development states (extensively) use PMSCs. An analysis of inter-temporal and cross-national (United States, British, German and French) patterns of security privatisation indicates that all the three theoretical models point out causes and conditions that are relevant for a comprehensive explanation, but none is sufficient alone. Therefore, the article uses both the models and the empirical evidence to propose a synthetic perspective, which treats different explanatory conditions and logics as complementary, rather than rival. Going beyond the atheoretical conclusion that a multitude of disconnected factors are in some way relevant for a comprehensive explanation of security privatisation, I develop a thin and a thick synthesis that rely on a domain-of-application approach and sequencing, respectively. The thin synthesis spells out how different explanatory factors operate in specific domains, whereas the thick synthesis elaborates how different conditions and mechanisms apply to different phases of security privatisation and how they interrelate.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Avant, Deborah (2005) The Market for Force: The Consequences of Privatizing Security, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Avant, Deborah and Lee Sigelman (2010) ‘Private Security and Democracy: Lessons from the US in Iraq’, Security Studies 19 (2): 230–265.
Ballard, Kyle M. (2007) ‘The Privatization of Military Affairs: A Historical Look into the Evolution of the Private Military Industry’, in Thomas Jäger and Gerhard Kümmel, eds, Private Military and Security Companies: Chances, Problems and Pitfalls, 37–53, Wiesbaden: VS.
Bartling, Björn and Urs Fischbacher (2012) ‘Shifting the Blame: On Delegation and Responsibility’, The Review of Economic Studies 79 (1): 67–87.
Biddle, Stephen (2006) Military Power: Explaining Victory and Defeat in Modern Battle, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Binder, Martin (2007) ‘Norms versus Rationality: Why Democracies Use Private Military Companies in Civil Wars’, in Thomas Jäger and Gerhard Kümmel, eds, Private Military and Security Companies: Chances, Problems and Pitfalls, 307–320, Wiesbaden: VS.
Carmola, Kateri (2010) Private Security Contractors in the Age of New Wars: Risk, Law and Ethics, London: Routledge.
Chesterman, Simon and Chia Lehnardt (2007) ‘Conclusion: From Mercenaries to Market’, in Simon Chesterman and Chia Lehnardt, eds, From Mercenaries to Market: The Rise and Regulation of Private Military Companies, 251–256, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Cockayne, James (2007) ‘Make or Buy? Principal-Agent-Theory and the Regulation of Private Military Companies’, in Simon Chesterman and Chia Lehnardt, eds, From Mercenaries to Market: The Rise and Regulation of Private Military Companies, 196–216, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Collmer, Sabine (2011) ‘The Afghanistan Conundrum: Troop Surge or Civilian Capacity Building? German Public Opinion towards a Difficult Mission’, in Marjan Malešič and Gerhard Kümmel, eds, Security and the Military between Reality and Perception, 17–30, Baden-Baden: Nomos.
Congressional Budget Office (2008) ‘Contractor's Support of U.S. Operations in Iraq’, Report for the Senate Committee on the Budget, 12 August, Washington DC: Congressional Budget Office.
Cortell, Andrew P. and Susan Peterson (1999) ‘Altered States: Explaining Domestic Institutional Change’, British Journal of Political Science 29 (1): 177–203.
Cutler, Anne C. (2010) ‘The Legitimacy of Private Transnational Governance: Experts and the Transnational Market for Force’, Socio-Economic Review 8 (1): 157–185.
Deitelhoff, Nicole (2008) ‘Ohne private Sicherheitsanbieter können die USA nicht mehr Krieg führen – Die Privatisierung der RMA’, in Jan Helmig and Niklas Schörnig, eds, Die Transformation der Streitkräfte im 21. Jahrhundert: Militärische und politische Dimensionen der aktuellen ‘Revolution in Military Affairs’, 165–184, Frankfurt: Campus.
Deitelhoff, Nicole (2010) ‘Private Security and Military Companies: The Other Side of Business and Conflict’, in Nicole Deitelhoff and Klaus D. Wolf, eds, Corporate Security Responsibility? Corporate Governance Contributions to Peace and Security in Zones of Conflict, 177–201, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Deitelhoff, Nicole and Anna Geis (2010) ‘Entkernt sich der Leviathan? Die organisatorische und funktionelle Umrüstung der Militär- und Verteidigungspolitik westlicher Demokratien’, Leviathan 38 (3): 389–410.
De Nevers, Renée (2009a) ‘Private Security Companies and the Laws of War’, Security Dialogue 40 (2): 169–190.
De Nevers, Renée (2009b) ‘(Self) Regulating War? Voluntary Regulation and the Private Security Industry’, Security Studies 18 (3): 479–516.
Department of Defense (1996) ‘Improving the Combat Edge through Outsourcing’, DoD Report, 1 March, Washington DC: Department of Defense.
Department of Defense (2010) ‘Policy and Procedures for Determining Workforce Mix’, DoD Instruction 1100.22, 12 April, Washington DC: Department of Defense.
Donald, Dominick (2006) After the Bubble: British Private Security Companies after Iraq, London: RUSI.
Dunigan, Molly (2011) Victory for Hire: Private Security Companies’ Impact on Military Effectiveness, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Finnemore, Martha (1996) ‘Norms, Culture, and World Politics: Insights from Sociology’s Institutionalism’, International Organization 50 (2): 325–347.
Finnemore, Martha and Kathryn Sikkink (1998) ‘International Norm Dynamics and Political Change’, International Organization 52 (4): 887–917.
Flinders, Matthew and Jim Buller (2006) ‘Depoliticisation: Principles, Tactics and Tools’, British Politics 1 (3): 293–318.
Fuchs, Doris (2005) Understanding Business Power in Global Governance, Baden-Baden: Nomos.
Gansler, Jacques S. (1996) Defense Conversion: Transforming the Arsenal of Democracy, Boston, MA: MIT Press.
Gates, Robert M. (2009) ‘Defense Budget Recommendation Statement’, 6 April, Arlington, VA.
Government Accountability Office (1994) ‘Government Contractors: Measuring Costs of Service Contractors versus Federal Employees’, GAO/GGD-94-95, 10 March, Washington DC: Government Accountability Office.
Government Accountability Office (2003) ‘Military Operations: Contractors Provide Vital Service to Deployed Forces but are Not Adequately Addressed in DoD Plans’, GAO-03-695, 24 June, Washington DC: Government Accountability Office.
Government Accountability Office (2006) ‘Rebuilding Iraq: Actions Still Needed to Improve Use of Private Security Providers’, GAO-06-865, 13 June, Washington DC: Government Accountability Office.
German Federal Government (2011) ‘Antwort der Bundesregierung auf eine Große Anfrage zum Thema Regulierung privater Militär- und Sicherheitsfirmen’, 5 August, Berlin: German Parliament.
Giscard d’Estaing, Louis and Bernard Cazeneuve (2011) ‘Rapport d’information en conclusion des travaux de la mission d’évaluation et de contrôle (MEC) sur les externalisations dans le domaine de la defense’, Report for the National Assembly, 5 July, Paris: National Assembly.
Gwartney, Joshua, Robert Lawson and Joshua Hall (2011) Economic Freedom of the World: 2011 Annual Report, Vancouver, BC: Fraser Institute.
Hawkins, Darren G., David A. Lake, Daniel L. Nielson and Michael J. Tierney, eds (2006) ‘Delegation Under Anarchy: States, International Organizations, and Principal-Agent Theory’, in Delegation and Agency in International Organizations, 3–38, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Heritage Foundation (2012) ‘Country Rankings’, http://www.heritage.org/index/ranking, (accessed 30 May, 2012).
Hood, Christopher (2002) ‘The Risk Game and the Blame Game’, Government and Opposition 37 (1): 15–37.
Isenberg, David (2009) Shadow Force: Private Security Contractors in Iraq, Westport, CT: Praeger.
Isenberg, David (2010) ‘When the U.S., U.K. and France All Do It’, 30 November, http://www.huffingtonpost.com/david-isenberg/when-the-us-uk-and-france_b_790204.html, (accessed 24 February, 2012).
Jankowski, Barbara (2011) ‘French Public Support for Military Operations: The Challenge of the War in Afghanistan’, in Marjan Malešič and Gerhard Kümmel, eds, Security and the Military between Reality and Perception, 43–54, Baden-Baden: Nomos.
Jupille, Joseph, James Caporaso and Jeffrey T. Checkel (2003) ‘Integrating Institutions: Rationalism, Constructivism, and the Study of the European Union’, Comparative Political Studies 36 (1–2): 7–40.
Kinsey, Christopher (2006) Corporate Soldiers and International Security: The Rise of Private Military Companies, London: Routledge.
Kinsey, Christopher (2009) Private Contractors and the Reconstruction of Iraq: Transforming Military Logistics, London: Routledge.
Krahmann, Elke (2005) ‘Controlling Private Military Companies in the UK and Germany: Between Partnership and Regulation’, European Security 14 (2): 277–295.
Krahmann, Elke (2008) ‘Security: Collective Good or Commodity?’, European Journal of International Relations 14 (3): 379–404.
Krahmann, Elke (2010) States, Citizens and the Privatization of Security, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kruck, Andreas (2011) Private Ratings, Public Regulations: Credit Rating Agencies and Global Financial Governance, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Leander, Anna (2005) ‘The Power to Construct International Security: On the Significance of Private Military Companies’, Millennium 33 (3): 803–826.
Leander, Anna (2010) ‘The Paradoxical Impunity of Private Military Companies: Authority and the Limits to Legal Accountability’, Security Dialogue 41 (5): 467–490.
Leander, Anna and Rens van Munster (2007) ‘Private Security Contractors in the Debate about Darfur: Reflecting and Reinforcing Neo-liberal Governmentality’, International Relations 21 (2): 201–216.
Mello, Patrick (2010) ‘In Search of New Wars: The Debate about a Transformation of War’, European Journal of International Relations 16 (2): 297–309.
Ménard, Christian and Jean-Claude Viollet (2012) ‘Rapport d’information par la Commission de la défense nationale et des forces armées sur les sociétés militaires privées’, Report for the National Assembly, 14 February, Paris: National Assembly.
Mueller, John E. (1973) War, Presidents and Public Opinion, New York: Wiley.
Nölke, Andreas (2004) ‘Transnational Private Authority and Corporate Governance’, in Stefan A. Schirm, ed., New Rules for Global Markets: Public and Private Governance in the World Economy, 155–175, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Petersohn, Ulrich (2006) ‘Die Nutzung privater Militärfirmen durch US-Streitkräfte und Bundeswehr’, Study No. 36/2006, Berlin: German Institute for International and Security Affairs.
Petersohn, Ulrich (2010) ‘Sovereignty and Privatizing the Military: An Institutional Explanation’, Contemporary Security Policy 31 (3): 531–552.
Petersohn, Ulrich (2011) ‘Military Privatisation: Changing the Military-Civil Force Mix’, European Political Science 10 (2): 146–156.
Pfeffer, Jeffrey and Gerald R. Salancik (2003) The External Control of Organizations: A Resource Dependence Perspective, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Pierson, Paul (2004) Politics in Time: History, Institutions, and Social Analysis, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Pollack, Mark A. (2003) The Engines of European Integration: Delegation, Agency, and Agenda Setting in the European Union, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Prasad, Monica (2006) The Politics of Free Markets: The Rise of Neoliberal Economic Policies in Britain, France, Germany and the United States, Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.
Rittberger, Berthold (2012) ‘Institutionalizing Representative Democracy in the European Union: The Case of the European Parliament’, Journal of Common Market Studies 50 (S1): 18–37.
Rosén, Frederik (2008) ‘Commercial Security: Conditions of Growth’, Security Dialogue 39 (1): 77–97.
Schmeidl, Susanne (2008) ‘Case Study Afghanistan’, in Ulrike Joras and Adrian Schuster, eds, Private Security Companies and Local Publications: An Exploratory Study of Afghanistan and Angola, 9–38, Bern: Swisspeace.
Schneiker, Andrea (2007) ‘National Regulatory Regimes for PMSCs and their Activities: Benefits and Shortcomings’, in Thomas Jäger and Gerhard Kümmel, eds, Private Military and Security Companies: Chances, Problems and Pitfalls, 407–418, Wiesbaden: VS.
Schörnig, Niklas (2008) ‘Casualty Aversion in Democratic Security Provision: Procurement and the Defense Industrial Base’, in Matthew Evangelista, Harald Müller and Niklas Schörnig, eds, Democracy and Security: Preferences, Norms and Policy-Making, 14–35, London: Routledge.
Schwartz, Moshe (2010) ‘The Department of Defense's Use of Private Security Contractors in Iraq and Afghanistan: Background, Analysis, and Options for Congress’, Report for the Congress, 22 June, Washington DC: Congressional Research Service.
Shearer, David (1999) ‘Private Military Force and Challenges for the Future’, Cambridge Review of International Affairs 13 (1): 80–94.
Singer, Peter W. (2005) ‘Outsourcing War’, Foreign Affairs 84 (2): 119–132.
Singer, Peter W. (2008) Corporate Warriors: The Rise of the Privatized Military Industry, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Spearin, Christopher (2008) ‘Private, Armed and Humanitarian? States, NGOs, International Private Security Companies and Shifting Humanitarianism’, Security Dialogue 39 (4): 363–382.
Taylor, Trevor (2011) ‘Private Security Companies in Iraq and Beyond’, International Affairs 87 (2): 445–456.
Wolf, Klaus D. (1999) ‘The New Raison d′état as a Problem for Democracy in World Society’, European Journal of International Relations 5 (3): 333–363.
Zamparelli, Steven J. (1999) ‘Contractors on the Battlefield: What Have We Signed up for?’ Air Force Journal of Logistics 23 (3): 11–19.
Acknowledgements
The author would like to thank Christopher Daase, Nicole Deitelhoff, Tine Hanrieder, Rainer Hülsse, Elke Krahmann, Karen Lund Petersen, Alexander Spencer, Bernhard Zangl, the anonymous reviewers and the editors of JIRD for very helpful comments on earlier versions of this article.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kruck, A. Theorising the use of private military and security companies: a synthetic perspective. J Int Relat Dev 17, 112–141 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1057/jird.2013.4
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/jird.2013.4