Abstract
Healthcare stakeholders require accurate and reliable models to aid performance management, but there is an issue as to whether deterministic or stochastic modelling is more appropriate. Deterministic models are usually simpler, more easily understood, and less data intensive. However, stochastic models tend to be more realistic, but require significant data to develop a realistic model. We illustrate that when queueing is a defining property of the problem semantics then we need suitable data and a model that allows us to describe and characterise the relationship between the queueing process, its parameters and delay. By comparing an analytic deterministic model with a stochastic simulation of an orthopaedic Integrated Clinical Assessment and Treatment Service, we show that when uncertainty is ignored in the planning stages then there will be a deficiency in the number of staff allocated. This causes queues to build up and it follows that patients will receive a diminished quality of care.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adan I, Bekkers J, Dellaert N, Vissers J and Yu X (2009). Patient mix optimisation and stochastic resource requirements: A case study in cardiothoracic surgery planning. Health Care Management Science 12 (2): 129–141.
Brailsford S (2007). Tutorial: Advances and challenges in healthcare simulation. In: Proceedings of the 2007 Winter Simulation Conference, Washington DC.
Concannon K, Elder M, Hindle K, Tremble J and Tse S (2007). Simulation Modelling with Simul8. Visual Thinking International: Canada.
Cote MJ (2000). Understanding Patient Flow. Decision Line, Vol. 31, pp 8–10.
Department of Health: Safety and Social Care of Health, Safety and Social Care of Health (2006a). Outline Service Specification for Orthopaedic ICATS in the Northern Health and Social Services Board Area. Department of Health, Social Services and Public Services: Belfast, Northern Ireland.
Department of Health: Safety and Social Care of Health (2006b). Southern Health and Social Services Board Orthopaedic ICATS Service Design Model. Department of Health, Safety and Social Care: Northern Ireland.
Department of Health (2008). NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement: Patient Flow, http://www.institute.nhs.uk/quality_and_service_improvement_tools/quality_and_service_improvement_tools/patient_flow.html, accessed 26 January 2013.
Dixon D, Pollard B, Rowley D and Johnson M (2010). Applications of the ICF to referral delay in total joint arthroplasty. Quality Safety in Health Care 19 (6): 1–3.
Fullerton KJ and Crawford VLS (1999). The winter bed crisis—quantifying seasonal effects on hospital bed usage. QJM: An International Journal of Medicine 92 (4): 199–206.
Gracey J, McDonagh S and Baxtor D (2002). Physiotherapy management of low back pain. Spline 27 (4): 406–411.
Gupta D and Denton B (2008). Appointment scheduling in health care: Challenges and Opportunities. IIE Transactions 40 (9): 800–819.
Hare WL, Alimada A, Dodd H, Ferguson R and Rutherford A (2009). A deterministic model of home and community care client counts in British Columbia. Health Care Management Science 12 (1): 80–98.
Hing E and Middleton K (2004). National hospital ambulatory medical care survey: 2002 Outpatient Department Summary. Advanced data from Vital and Health Statistics 1 (345): 1–35.
Iezzi J (2006). Multi-criteria decision making in outpatient scheduling. PhD Thesis, University of South Florida.
Klassen KJ and Rohleder TR (2004). Outpatient appointment scheduling with urgent clients in a dynamic, multi-period environment. Journal of Service Management 15 (2): 167–186.
Knight VA and Harper PR (2012). Modelling emergency medical services with phase-type distributions. Health Systems 1: 1–11.
Kokangul A (2008). A combination of deterministic and stochastic approaches to optimise bed capacity in a hospital unit. Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine 90: 56–65.
Marjamaa RA, Torkki PM, Hirvensalo EJ and Kirvela OA (2009). What is the best workflow for an operating room? A simulation study of five scenarios. Health care Management Science 12 (2): 142–146.
Marshall AH, Vasilakis C and El-Darzi E (2005). Length of stay-based patient flow models: Recent developments and future directions. Health Care Management Science 8 (3): 213–220.
National Health Service Foundation Trust (2012). About physiotherapy. http://www.chelwest.nhs.uk/services/therapy-services/msk-physio/faqs, accessed 25 January 2013.
Saka O, McGuire A and Wolfe C (2009). Cost of stroke in the United Kingdom. Age and Ageing 38 (1): 27–32.
Speed CA and Crisp AJ (2005). Referrals to hospital-based rheumatology and orthopaedic services: Seeking direction. Rheumatology 44 (10): 469–471.
Vissers JMH, Adan IJBF and Bekkers JA (2005). Patient mix optimisation in tactical cardiothoracic surgery planning: A case study. IMA journal of Management Mathematics 16 (3): 281–304.
Webb M (2009). Orthopaedic Triage: Evidence for the Effectiveness of Clinical Assessment Teams. National Public Health Service for Wales: Cardiff.
Weston-Simons J, Jack CM, Doctor C, Brogan K, Reed D and Ricketts D (2012). The impact of snow on orthopaedic trauma referrals. Injury 43 (7): 1033–1036.
Wiles CM et al (2001). Controlled randomised crossover trial of the effects of physiotherapy on mobility in chronic multiple sclerosis. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry with Practical Neurology 70 (2): 174–179.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported through the UK MATCH Programme, Engineering & Physical Science Research Grant EP/F063822/1. Views expressed in this work are entirely those of the authors.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gillespie, J., McClean, S., FitzGibbons, F. et al. Do we need stochastic models for healthcare? The case of ICATS?. J Simulation 8, 293–303 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1057/jos.2014.8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/jos.2014.8