Abstract
Unsafe abortion continues to be a major contributor to maternal mortality and morbidity around the world. This article examines the role of pharmacists in expanding women's access to safe medical abortion in Latin America, Africa, and Asia. Available research shows that although pharmacists and pharmacy workers often sell abortion medications to women, accurate information about how to use the medications safely and effectively is rarely offered. No publication covered effective interventions by pharmacists to expand access to medical abortion, but lessons can be learned from successful interventions with other reproductive health services. To better serve women, increasing awareness and improving training for pharmacists and pharmacy workers about unsafe abortion – and medications that can safely induce abortion – are needed.
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
Worldwide, women endure almost 22 million unsafe abortions each year, defined by the World Health Organization (WHO) as ‘a procedure for terminating an unwanted pregnancy either by persons lacking the necessary skills or in an environment lacking the minimal medical standards, or both’.1, 2 In this article, we summarize lessons learned from the literature about the role of pharmacists and pharmacies in ‘medical abortion’ or pregnancy termination with medications, in low-income settings in Latin America, Africa, and Asia, where 99 per cent of unsafe abortions take place.1 Innovative strategies for improving women's access to safe abortion services are needed in these regions to prevent morbidity and mortality in women.
Literature discussing the roles that pharmacists and pharmacy workers play in medical abortion throughout Latin America, Africa, and Asia provides the evidence base for this article. Two library science experts, working independently of one another, searched PubMed and Google Scholar, using >35 search terms. At the same time, to locate additional literature not available through the online searches, the co-authors contacted researchers conducting studies on pharmacies and medical abortion in the three regions.
Medical Abortion and Pharmacies
Medical abortion is safe and effective for ending unwanted pregnancy. Clinical studies support the combined use of mifepristone and misoprostol.3, 4, 5 Where mifepristone is not available, misoprostol alone can be used as a safe and effective abortifacient.6 As of 2011, in at least 45 countries, mifepristone was registered for abortion and pending in others;7 misoprostol was registered in more than 80 countries, primarily for the prevention and treatment of gastric ulcers.8 The WHO includes a mifepristone/misoprostol regimen for abortion up to 9 weeks of gestation on its Complementary Model List of Essential Medicines; misoprostol is included for treatment of incomplete and missed abortion.9
With greater availability of these promising drugs,8, 10 pharmacists – often first-line health-care providers in the developing world – have an increasingly important role to play in delivering accurate information about and increasing access to such methods. Pharmacies (also called chemist shops and drugstores) sell medications. They are often the most available health-care outlet in communities.11 Pharmacy waiting times usually are short and services, including information and direct sales of medications, often less costly than those of other health-care providers.12, 13, 14 Trained pharmacists and pharmacy employees have successfully delivered care related to stigmatized health conditions, including sexually transmitted infections (STIs), family planning, and emergency contraception (EC). Their success has been due to their ability to facilitate rapid access to medications, supplies, medical information, and advice while maintaining client confidentiality.11, 13, 15
Despite the potential advantages of working through pharmacies, there are challenges for ensuring accurate information and quality care.14 In many developing countries, there are few trained professional pharmacists; those who are well trained may not always be present in the pharmacies where they work.13, 14 Pharmacy employees, many with low levels of education and without formal pharmacy training, sell medications without prescriptions or support from a trained health-care professional.12, 16 This often leads to inaccurate advice and incorrect dispensing.12, 14, 17 The medications they sell may be unnecessary, ineffective, or even dangerous.
Pharmacy provision of medical abortion in Africa, Asia, and Latin America
Women seek pharmacists’ guidance when they want to end unwanted pregnancies, both in ‘legally restrictive settings’ (where abortion is fully illegal or is only allowed for specific reasons, such as to save the life of the woman or in cases of rape) and in more ‘liberal settings’ (where abortion is permissible for broader health and social circumstances). Table 1 summarizes findings from studies conducted about pharmacies and medical abortion throughout Latin America, Africa, and Asia.
Research elucidates challenges to facilitating medical abortion through pharmacies.
-
The unwillingness of pharmacists to stock and dispense mifepristone and/or misoprostol.
-
The lack of information and knowledge about medical abortion among pharmacy personnel, often exacerbated because misoprostol is rarely registered or labeled for abortion. Thus, effective doses are often unknown to pharmacists and the women seeking help.
As Table 1 shows, pharmacy workers may be apprehensive about informing and counseling women about abortifacients. The reasons include: worry about risk to their employment; ethical, moral, and religious grounds; fear of backlash from anti-abortion groups; and perceptions that physicians, rather than pharmacy workers, should provide such information. Even pharmacists and pharmacy workers who were willing to provide information and sell the medicines often gave customers incorrect or incomplete information about the route of administration, dosages, side effects, and gestational limits for medications used for medical abortion. Some countries, such as Brazil and Vietnam, restrict stocking and distribution of medical abortion medications to authorized sites, thereby excluding non-hospital-based pharmacies (Table 1).
Studies also show that pharmacists do dispense misoprostol, regardless of local regulations intended to prevent pharmacists from prescribing medications and that they frequently do not request a prescription. In restrictive and liberal settings alike, pharmacists often sell medicines that are ineffective abortifacients and may be unsafe (Table 1). In South Asia, many pharmacists and pharmacy workers recommend allopathic, ayurvedic, or homeopathic drugs, although their effectiveness for abortion has not been clinically evaluated. In Latin America and Africa, pharmacists and pharmacy workers incorrectly recommended contraceptive methods, including EC, as abortifacients.
Where abortion is legally restricted, low-income women have even more difficulty accessing safe abortion services than do women with resources, yet medications for inducing abortion safely may be available. Studies in Mexico, the Dominican Republic, and Argentina show that pharmacies in low-income neighborhoods are more likely to carry misoprostol than those in medium- to high-income areas.18, 22, 23 Research in four regions of Mexico showed independent privately owned pharmacies, and those located in low-income areas, to have been significantly more likely to sell misoprostol by the pill than chain pharmacies and those in medium-income areas.18 Pharmacy managers may be responding to demand generated by low-income women for a safe and relatively inexpensive alternative to unsafe abortions.
Approaches to working with pharmacists
Although efforts have been made to extend the range and quality of reproductive health services offered at pharmacies, including counseling, information, and sales of medications, we found no publications about how pharmacists can improve access to safe medical abortion. Communities, governments, non-governmental organizations, and international organizations have asked pharmacists and pharmacy workers to improve access to EC, contraceptives in general, and medications for STIs. Thus, we draw on literature from other areas of sexual and reproductive health, including studies on interventions with other sorts of health-care professionals, to explore the potential for expanding the role of pharmacists in medical abortion.
Non-physician clinicians (including midwives, nurse practitioners, clinical officers, and physician assistants) can deliver safe abortion care.31, 32, 33, 34, 35 Studies demonstrate that maintaining abortion services strictly within the confines of physician-only practices is unnecessary. Other types of providers can offer safe and effective abortions – including medical ones. Pharmacists, however, do not traditionally fall within the definition of a midlevel provider or even health-care provider. Their role as service providers or facilitators who can connect with other cadres of providers to increase access to medical abortion has yet to be examined. Nor have researchers yet studied the ability of pharmacists to screen women for appropriate gestational age and lack of risk factors (for example, ectopic pregnancy) for medical abortion.
In both liberal and restrictive settings, strategies to work with pharmacists must take into account local policies and context; these are often controversial or confusing. For example:
-
Mifepristone and/or misoprostol may be registered in countries but are not for sale in readily accessible pharmacies.
-
Pharmacists may not be legally authorized to sell medical abortion medications without prescriptions; these prescriptions may not be available to lower-income women, who cannot afford to see anyone other than a pharmacist for their care.
-
Pharmacists or pharmacy workers may not be trained to advise consumers on the correct use of medications.
-
Pharmacists and pharmacy workers may have moral objections to abortion and refuse to sell medications, even when the consumer has a prescription.
Social marketing and detailing
Social marketing applies commercial marketing strategies to social causes and often sells an associated product at a subsidized rate. Developing a network of retailers to sell a specific product and thus increasing product promotion and distribution by raising awareness through advertising, packaging, and branding is a typical approach. Social marketing may also include training programs for pharmacy personnel (often through educational outreach visits, also known as academic or medical detailing) and development and distribution of information, education, and communication materials for pharmacists, pharmacy workers, and clients. Social marketing that has already been applied to reproductive health products could likely be a successful mechanism to enhance pharmacy staff capacity and provide quality medications as part of a broader medical abortion strategy.36, 37 A challenge of social marketing is finding ongoing support or a subsidy for sustainability. Ultimately, products and services need to be profitable to those who provide them, and affordable to those who need them.
A 1997 Cochrane Systematic Review on the use of academic detailing included two studies on pharmacists and pharmacy workers. Detailing visits included talking with pharmacists about evidence-based information and leaving them with written information, with the objective of improving the advice and information they offer to clients. Individualized outreach visits, particularly when combined with social marketing, did affect provider behaviors, especially prescribing. The intensity (measured in the number of detailing visits) needed, the sustainability of this effect over time, and cost-effectiveness, remain unknown.38, 39
Pharmacists in a Kenyan study expressed preference for detailers to offer regular updates to pharmacy staff on the use of emergency contraceptives. They viewed the visits as a good method for reminding pharmacy staff about the importance of providing clients with information about emergency contraceptives while making the sale.40
Pharmacist training
Training of pharmacists using materials, referral links, and refresher courses has met with some success, but without strong evidence for longer-term impact.13, 41 In Lima, Peru, an intervention study in 14 of the city's 24 lowest socio-economic districts showed that training pharmacists and physicians in STI management and linking them through a formalized referral network strengthened the connection and communication between the two professions and improved their recommendations to clients for STI treatment regimens.15 A 1-day program in Ghana on effective drug treatments for STIs with pharmacists resulted in better prescribing practices for urethral discharge.13 In Mexico City, pharmacy workers became slightly more willing to offer information about condoms after a training about STI treatment and HIV/AIDS prevention; the information was more accurate than that offered by pharmacy workers who did not participate in any training.42 The need to conduct one-on-one training to accommodate individual schedules makes comprehensive training expensive. Only training reinforced by refresher sessions sustained gains long term.13, 42
Health-care referral systems
Referral systems between pharmacists and other health-care providers have helped women receive appropriate care.15 In a randomized control trial, in a program that trained pharmacists to identify and manage STDs, use of referral cards improved communication between pharmacists and physicians, facilitating continuity of care.15 In Brazil, training pharmacy workers only to refer people to the public health system for care was not effective, because consumers looked to pharmacies for a solution, not simply for a referral.14
Discussion
As pharmacists and pharmacy workers often sell something to customers to end a pregnancy, it is imperative that they learn about what is or is not effective for medical abortion, and where to refer women who need clinical attention. In many countries, medical abortion practice guidelines do not exist, thus limiting information on up-to-date drug options and evidence-based practices. Misoprostol, moreover, does not have package labeling for its use in abortion care. Regulations that guide pharmacist practices may limit prescribing of medications or selling them over-the-counter. Where medical abortion is available in some form, programs that build referral networks among clinicians prescribing medical abortion and pharmacists who stock and sell the product may reach more women than single-profession interventions.
Successful interventions must address what hinders pharmacists: lack of training in counseling during pharmacy school; shortage of trained pharmacists in pharmacies throughout the world; and client concerns about confidentiality. Strong links with other health-care providers can address pharmacists’ inability to confirm physical findings of pregnancy (beyond what a woman reports) and address complications. Because pharmacists are often also business owners, they want to know how expanding and improving services for women with unwanted pregnancies can improve pharmacy practices and pharmacists’ livelihoods.
Conclusion
Even where pharmacists’ knowledge about medical abortion is limited, many are willing to provide something to help a woman with an unwanted pregnancy. Women already seek medicines from pharmacists to end unwanted pregnancy, but some of these women are unable or unwilling to seek care from a trained clinical provider. Approaches that successfully improve pharmacists’ ability and willingness to provide accurate information about medications as well as referrals to other health-care providers can help women benefit from safe and effective medical abortions. To date, such approaches and interventions have not been documented. When they are, they will need to be carefully tested and rigorously evaluated. The specific roles of pharmacists in medical abortion will depend on a country's legal and policy context. Research is needed to test strategies that enable pharmacists to collaborate effectively with other health-care providers and thus reduce unsafe abortions and increase women's access to safe abortion services.
References
WHO. (2011) Unsafe Abortion: Global and Regional Estimates of the Incidence of Unsafe Abortion and Associated Mortality in 2008, 6th edn. Geneva: World Health Organization.
WHO. (1992) The Prevention and Management of Unsafe Abortion. Report of a technical working group. Geneva: World Health Organization. Report no. WHO/MSM/92.5.
Tang, O.S., Chan, C.C., Ng, E.H., Lee, S.W. and Ho, P.C. (2003) A prospective, randomized, placebo-controlled trial on the use of mifepristone with sublingual or vaginal misoprostol for medical abortions of less than 9 weeks gestation. Human Reproduction 18 (11): 2315–2318.
von Hertzen, H. et al (2003) WHO multinational study of three misoprostol regimens after mifepristone for early medical abortion. I: Efficacy. British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 110 (9): 808–818.
Winikoff, B. et al (2008) Two distinct oral routes of misoprostol in mifepristone medical abortion: A randomized controlled trial. Obstetrics and Gynecology 112 (6): 1303–1310.
von Hertzen, H. et al (2007) Efficacy of two interval and two routes of administration of misoprostol for termination of early pregnancy: A randomised controlled equivalence trial. The Lancet 369: 1938–1946.
Gynuity Health Projects. (2009) Mifepristone approval map, http://gynuity.org/resources/info/map-of-mifepristone-approval/, accessed 2 April 2011.
Fernandez, M.M., Coeytaux, F., de Leon, R.G. and Harrison, D.L. (2009) Assessing the global availability of misoprostol. International Journal of Gynaecology and Obstetrics 105 (2): 180–186.
WHO. (2010) WHO model list of essential medicine: World Health Organization, http://www.who.int/medicines/publications/essentialmedicines/Updated_sixteenth_adult_list_en.pdf, accessed 2 April 2011.
Sherris, J., Bingham, A., Burns, M.A., Girvin, S., Westley, E. and Gomez, P.I. (2005) Misoprostol use in developing countries: Results from a multicountry study. International Journal of Gynaecology and Obstetrics 88 (1): 76–81.
Nikajima, H. and Steinbach, D. (1997) The Role of the Pharmacist in the Fight against the HIV/AIDS Pandemic: A Joint Declaration between the World Health Organization and the International Pharmaceutical Federation. Geneva: World Health Organization.
Chalker, J., Chuc, N.T., Falkenberg, T., Do, N.T. and Tomson, G. (2000) STD management by private pharmacies in Hanoi: Practice and knowledge of drug sellers. Sexually Transmitted Infections 76 (4): 299–302.
Mayhew, S., Nzambi, K., Pepin, J. and Adjei, S. (2001) Pharmacists’ role in managing sexually transmitted infections: Policy issues and options for Ghana. Health Policy and Planning 16 (2): 152–160.
Ramos, M.C. et al (2004) Pharmacy clerks’ prescribing practices for STD patients in Porto Alegre, Brazil: Missed opportunities for improving STD control. International Journal of STD & AIDS 15 (5): 333–336.
Garcia, P., Hughes, J., Carcamo, C. and Holmes, K.K. (2003) Training pharmacy workers in recognition, management, and prevention of STDs: District-randomized controlled trial. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 81 (11): 806–814.
Goel, P., Ross-Degnan, D., Berman, P. and Soumerai, S. (1996) Retail pharmacies in developing countries: A behavior and intervention framework. Social Science & Medicine 42 (8): 1155–1161.
Ehrle, N. and Sarker, M. (2011) Emergency contraceptive pills: Knowledge and attitudes of pharmacy personnel in Managua, Nicaragua. International Perspectives on Sexual and Reproductive Health 37 (2): 67–74.
Lara, D., García, S.G., Wilson, K.S. and Paz, F. (2011) How often and under which circumstances do Mexican pharmacy vendors recommend misoprostol to induce an abortion? International Perspectives on Sexual and Reproductive Health 37 (2): 75–83.
Billings, D.L., Walker, D., Mainero del Paso, G., Clark, K.A. and Dayananda, I. (2009) Pharmacy worker practices related to use of misoprostol for abortion in one Mexican state. Contraception 79 (6): 445–451.
Lara, D., Abuabara, K., Grossman, D. and Diaz-Olavarrieta, C. (2006) Pharmacy provision of medical abortifacients in a Latin American city. Contraception 74 (5): 394–399.
Ganatra, B., Manning, V. and Pallipamulla, S.P. (2005) Availability of medical abortion pills and the role of chemists: A study from Bihar and Jharkhand, India. Reproductive Health Matters 13 (26): 65–74.
Miller, S. et al (2005) Misoprostol and declining abortion-related morbidity in Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic: A temporal association. British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 112 (9): 1291–1296.
Zamberlin, N. and Gianni, C. (eds.) (2008) Acceso, saberes y experiencias acerca del aborto con medicamentos: El circuito del misoprostol en la Ciudad de Buenos Aires. Presented at the Third Research Meeting on Unwanted Pregnancy and Unsafe Abortion: Public Health Challenges in Latin America and the Caribbean; 7–10 October; Mexico City.
Ramachandar, L. and Pelto, P.J. (2005) Medical abortion in rural Tamil Nadu, South India: A quiet transformation. Reproductive Health Matters 13 (26): 54–64.
Akiode, A., Fetters, T., Okoh, M., Dah, T., Akwuba, B. and Oji, E. (2007) The Availability of Misoprostol in Pharmacies and Patent Medicine Stores in Two Nigerian Cities. Chapel Hill, NC: Ipas.
Ong'ech, J., Osur, J., Makanyengo, M., Mathai, M., Gebreselassie, H. and Brookman-Amissah, E. (2008) The Status of Misoprostol Use in Kenya. Nairobi: Ipas Africa Alliance and the National Health and Development Organization (NAHEDO).
Cohen, J., Ortiz, O., Llaguno, S.E., Goodyear, L., Billings, D. and Martinez, I. (2005) Reaching women with instructions on misoprostol use in a Latin American country. Reproductive Health Matters 13 (26): 84–92.
Tamang, A. and Tamang, J. (2005) Availability and acceptability of medical abortion in Nepal: Health care providers’ perspectives. Reproductive Health Matters 13 (26): 110–119.
Agência Nacional de Vigilância Sanitária, Brasil. (2001) Resolução RE nº 905, de 21 de junho, http://www.anvisa.gov.br/anvisalegis/resol/905_01re.htm, accessed 20 January 2012.
Ganatra, B., Bygdeman, M., Phan, B.T., Nguyen, D.V. and Vu, M.L. (2004) From research to reality: The challenges of introducing medical abortion into service delivery in Vietnam. Reproductive Health Matters 12 (24): 105–113.
Patel, L., Bennet, T.A., Halpern, C.T., Johnston, H.B. and Suchindran, C.M. (2009) Support for provision of early medical abortion by mid-level providers in Bihar and Jharkhand, India. Reproductive Health Matters 17 (33): 70–79.
Yarnall, J., Swica, Y. and Winikoff, B. (2009) Non-physician clinicians can safely provide first trimester medical abortion. Reproductive Health Matters 17 (33): 61–69.
Berer, M. (2009) Provision of abortion by mid-level providers: International policy, practice and perspectives. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 87 (1): 58–63.
WHO. (1997) Medical Methods for Termination of Pregnancy. Geneva: WHO.
Warriner, L.K. et al (2011) Can midlevel health-care providers administer early medical abortion as safely and effectively as doctors? A randomized controlled equivalence trial in Nepal. The Lancet 377 (9772): 1155–1161.
Armand, F. (2003) Social Marketing Models for Product-based Reproductive Health Programs: A Comparative Analysis. Washington DC: USAID/Commercial Market Strategies Project.
Husain, S. and Shaikh, B.T. (2005) Stalling HIV through social marketing: Prospects in Pakistan. Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association 55 (7): 294–298.
O'Brien, M.A.,, Oxman, A.D ., Davis, D.A., Haynes, R.B., Freemantle, N. and Harvey, E.L. (1997) Educational outreach visits: Effects on professional practice and health care outcomes. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. Issue 4: Article no. CD000409. DOI:10.1002/14651858.CD000409.
Farmer, A.P. et al (2008) Printed educational materials: Effects on professional practice and health care outcomes. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. Issue 3: Article no. CD004398.
Liambila, W., Obare, F. and Keesbury, J. (2010) Can private pharmacy providers offer comprehensive reproductive health services to users of emergency contraceptives? Evidence from Nairobi, Kenya. Patient Education and Counseling 81 (3): 368–373.
Adu-Sarkodie, Y., Steiner, M.J., Attafuah, J. and Tweedy, K. (2000) Syndromic management of urethral discharge in Ghanaian pharmacies. Sexually Transmitted Infections 76 (6): 439–442.
Pick, S., Reyes, J., Alvarez, M., Cohen, S., Craige, J. and Troya, A. (1996) AIDS prevention training for pharmacy workers in Mexico City. AIDS Care 8 (1): 55–69.
Acknowledgements
We thank Lynn Trenning for helping to locate relevant literature and Michele Lynn for editorial assistance.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
†Deborah L. Billings and Bela Ganatra were employed by Ipas at the time of researching this article.
How can pharmacists and pharmacies in Africa help improve the availability and safe and effective use of abortion medicines? This article draws on evidence in Africa and elsewhere to suggest a way forward to avoid unnecessary death and harm to women.
Rights and permissions
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivative Works 3.0 Unported License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/
About this article
Cite this article
Sneeringer, R., Billings, D., Ganatra, B. et al. Roles of pharmacists in expanding access to safe and effective medical abortion in developing countries: A review of the literature. J Public Health Pol 33, 218–229 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1057/jphp.2012.11
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/jphp.2012.11