Abstract
This article argues that, while it can be politically expedient for governments to engage with health inequalities, they cannot, within the confines of neo-liberalism, realistically propose actions that evidence suggests will effectively reduce them – such as tackling power inequalities, social status and connections or class inequality. Indeed, a dominant ‘policy paradigm’ prioritising economic growth restricts the ability of policy actors to imagine alternative, more equitable scenarios. In this context, some policy actors and researchers have devised a parallel fantasy world in which proximal, downstream, easily tackled exposures are posited as potential solutions to health inequalities. The consequence of this is a widespread public sector culture in which well-meaning policymakers, practitioners, researchers and members of the public collude in sustaining a ‘cargo cult’ of health behaviourism. In examining this situation, we draw on accounts and critiques of utopian thinking to help explain: (i) the remarkable persistence of policy proposals to tackle health inequalities via downstream interventions, in spite of the strength of evidence challenging such approaches; and (ii) the limited extent to which more upstream proposals inform policy debates. We argue Ruth Levitas’ notion of ‘utopia as method’ offers an imaginative and potentially useful avenue for future health inequalities research.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Acheson, D., Barker, D., Chambers, J., Graham, H., Marmot, M. and Whitehead, M. (1998) Independent Inquiry Into Inequalities in Health. London: Stationery Office.
Bambra, C., Smith, K.E., Garthwaite, K., Joyce, K.E. and Hunter, D.J. (2011) A labour of sisyphus? Public policy & health inequalities research in the UK from the black & acheson reports to the marmot review. Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health 65 (5): 399–406.
Bambra, C., Fox, D. and Scott-Samuel, A. (2005) Towards a politics of health. Health Promotion International 20 (2): 187–193.
Bartley, M. (2003) Health Inequality: An Introduction to Concepts, Theories and Methods. Cambridge, UK: Polity.
Bartley, M., Blane, D. and Davey Smith, G. (1998) Introduction: Beyond the black report. Sociology of Health & Illness 20 (5): 563–577.
Bitton, J., Cavaco, A., Gaye, A. and Jones, B. (eds) (2012) United We Act a scoping study and a symposium on connected communities, http://dm.ncl.ac.uk/benjones/files/2012/06/cc_book_download3.pdf, accessed on 7 June 2015.
Black, D. (Chairman) (1980) Inequalities in Health: Report of a Research Working Group. London: Department of Health and Social Security.
Buck, D. and Frosini, F. (2012) Clustering of Unhealthy Behaviours Over Time: Implications for Policy and Practice. London: The King’s Fund.
Cameron, D. (2012) Speech by Prime Minister David Cameron on welfare reform, at Bluewater, Kent on Monday 25 June 2012, http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/david-cameron/9354163/David-Camerons-welfare-speech-in-full.html.
Chaney, P. and Wincott, D. (2014) Envisioning the third sector’s welfare role: Critical discourse analysis of ‘post-devolution’ public policy in the UK 1998–2012. Social Policy & Administration 48 (7): 757–781.
Chapman, S. (2007) Public Health Advocacy and Tobacco Control – Making Smoking History. Oxford: Blackwell.
Collin, J. (2012) The future of tobacco control: Tobacco control, global health policy and development: Towards policy coherence in global governance. Tobacco Control 21 (2): 274–80.
Commission on Social Determinants of Health. (2008) Closing the gap in a generation: Health equity through action on the social determinants of health. Final Report of the Commission on Social Determinants of Health. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization.
Crawford, R. (1977) You are dangerous to your health: The ideology and politics of victim blaming. International Journal of Health Services 7 (4): 663–680.
Davey Smith, G., Dorling, D. and Shaw, M. (eds.) (2001) Poverty, inequality and health in Britain: 1800-2000 – A Reader. Bristol, UK: The Policy Press.
Department of Health. (1995) Variations In Health: What Can the Department of Health and the National Health Service Do? London: Department of Health.
Department of Health. (2003) Tackling Health Inequalities: A Programme for Action. London: Department of Health.
Department of Health. (2008) Health Inequalities: Progress and Next Steps. London: Department of Health.
Department of Health. (2009) Tackling Health Inequalities: 10 Years On. London: Department of Health.
Dietz, R. and O’Neill, D. (2013) Enough Is Enough: Building a Sustainable Economy in a World of Finite Resources. Abingdon, UK: Routledge.
Drever, F. and Whitehead, M. (eds.) (1997) Health inequalities decennial supplement. Series DS no. 15. Office For National Statistics. London: The Stationery Office.
Escobar, E. (2013) Final Report of the Commission on Fair Access to Political Influence. Biggar, Scotland: The Jimmy Reid Foundation.
Exworthy, M., Berney, L. and Powell, M. (2002) How great expectations in Westminster are dashed locally: The local implementation of national policy on health inequalities. Policy & Politics 30 (1): 79–96.
Freudenberg, N. (2014) Lethal but Legal – Corporations, Consumption and Protecting Public Health. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Friedli, L. (2013) What we’ve tried, hasn’t worked: The politics of assets based public health. Critical Public Health 23 (2): 131–145.
Fuller, S. (2005) The intellectual. Cambridge: Icon Books.
Garthwaite, K., Smith, K.E., Bambra, C. and Pearce, J. (in press) Desperately Seeking Reductions in Health Inequalities: Perspectives of UK researchers on past, present and future directions in health inequalities research. Sociology of Health and Illness.
Gilmore, A.B., Savell, E. and Collin, J. (2011) Public health, corporations and the new responsibility deal: Promoting partnerships with vectors of disease? Public Health 33 (1): 2–4.
Goodwin, B. and Taylor, K. (1982) The Politics of Utopia: A Study in Theory and Practice. London: Hutchinson University Library.
Graham, H. (1994) When Life’s a Drag: Women, Smoking and Disadvantage. Norwich, UK: HM Stationary Office.
Hacker, J.S. and Pierson, P. (2010) Winner-Take-All-Politics.: How Washington made the rich richer and turned its back on the middle class. New York: Simon & Schuster.
Hall, P.A. (1993) Policy paradigms, social learning, and the state: The case of economic policymaking in Britain. Comparative Politics 25 (3): 275–96.
Harvey, D. and Haraway, D. (1995) Nature, politics, and possibilities: A debate and discussion with David Harvey and Donna Haraway. Environment and Planning A: Society and Space 13 (5): 507–527.
Joyce, K.E., Smith, K.E., Sullivan, C. and Bambra, C. (2010) Most of industry’s shutting down up here...: Employability initiatives to tackle worklessness in areas of low labour market demand. Social Policy & Society 9 (3): 337–363.
Kateb, G. (1963) Utopia and its Enemies. New York: The Free Press of Glencoe.
Kingdon, J.W. (1995 [1984]) Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies, 2nd edn. New York: HarperCollins College Publishers.
Kolakowski, L. (1983) The death of utopia reconsidered. In: S.C. McMurrin (ed.) The Tanner Lectures on Human Values 4. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Krieger, N. (2001) Theories for social epidemiology in the 21st century: An ecosocial perspective. International Journal of Epidemiology 30 (4): 668–677.
Krieger, N. et al (2010) Who, and what, causes health inequities? Reflections on emerging debates from an exploratory Latin American/North American workshop. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 64 (9): 747–749.
Kumar, K. (1991) Utopianism. Milton Keynes, UK: Open University Press.
Labour Party. (1997) New Labour Because Britain Deserves Better: The Labour Party Manifesto. London: Labour Party.
Levitas, R. (2013) Utopia as Method: The Imaginary Reconstitution of Society. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
Link, B.G. and Phelan, J.C. (1995) Social conditions as fundamental causes of disease. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 35 (extra issue): 80–94.
Lorenc, T., Petticrew, M., Welch, V. and Tugwell, P. (2013) What types of interventions generate inequalities? Evidence from systematic reviews. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 67 (2): 190–193.
Mackenbach, J.P. (2010) Has the english strategy to address health inequalities failed? Social Science & Medicine 71 (7): 1249–53.
Mackenbach, J.P. (2011) Can we reduce health inequalities? An analysis of the English strategy (1997–2010). Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 5 (7): 568–75.
Mackenbach, J.P. (2012) The persistence of health inequalities in modern welfare states: The explanation of a paradox. Social Science & Medicine 75 (4): 761–769.
Marmot, M. (2010) Strategic Review of Health Inequalities in England post-2010. Marmot Review Final Report. London: University College London.
McCormack, C. and Pallister, M. (2009) The Wee Yellow Butterfly. Edinburgh, UK: Argyll publishing.
Mead, M. (1971) Towards more vivid utopias. chapter 2. In: G. Kateb (ed.) Utopia. New York: Atherton Press, pp. 41–56.
Mumford, L. (1923) The Story of Utopias: Ideal Commonwealths and Social Myths. London: George Harrap & Co.
NICE. (2007) Behaviour Change at Population, Community and Individual Levels. London: National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence.
O’Hara, M. (2014) Austerity Bites: A journey to the sharp end of cuts in the UK. Bristol, UK: Policy Press.
Osborne, G. (2013) Speech by the chanceller of the exchequer, george osborne, on regulating the banking system, given at JP morgan in bournemouth on 4 February 2013, http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/banksandfinance/9847127/George-Osbornes-speech-in-full.html.
Oxfam. (2015) Wealth: Having it all and wanting more. Oxfam issue briefing, http://www.oxfam.org/sites/www.oxfam.org/files/file_attachments/ib-wealth-having-all-wanting-more-190115-en.pdf.
Phelan, J.C., Link, B.G., Diez-Roux, A., Kawachi, I. and Levin, B. (2004) ‘Fundamental causes’ of social inequalities in mortality: A test of the theory. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 45 (3): 265–285.
Piketty, T. (2014) Capital in the Twenty-First Century. [Translated by Goldhammer, A.] Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Popay, J., Whitehead, M. and Hunter, D.J. (2010) Injustice if killing people on a large scale – But what is to be done about it? Journal of Public Health 32 (2): 148–149.
Saunders, P. (2010) Beware False Prophets: Equality, the Good Society and The Spirit Level. London: Policy Exchange.
Sayer, A. (2014) Why We Can’t Afford the Rich. Bristol, UK: Policy Press.
Scambler, G. (2007) Social structure and the production, reproduction and durability of health inequalities. Social Theory and Health 5 (4): 297–315.
Scambler, G. (2009) Capitalists, workers and health: Illness as a ‘side-effect’ of profit-making. Social Theory and Health 7 (2): 117–128.
Scambler, G. (2012) Review article: Health inequalities. Sociology of Health and Illness 34 (1): 130–146.
Schmidt, V. (2010) Taking ideas and discourse seriously: Explaining change through discursive institutionalism as the fourth ‘new institutionalism’. European Political Science Review 21 (1): 1–25.
Schrecker, T. (2013) Can health equity survive epidemiology? Standards of proof and social determinants of health. Preventive medicine 57 (6): 741–744.
Schulz, A.J. and Mullings, L. (eds.) (2006) Gender, Race, Class and Health: Intersectional Approaches. San Francisco, CA: Jossey Bass.
Scott, S., Curnock, E., Mitchell, R., Robinson, M., Taulbut, M., Tod, E. and McCartney, G. (2013) What Would it Take to Eradicate Health Inequalities? Testing the Fundamental Causes Theory of Health Inequalities in Scotland. Glasgow: NHS Health Scotland, http://www.scotpho.org.uk/downloads/scotphoreports/scotpho131018_whatwouldittake_report.pdf.
Scott-Samuel, A., Bambra, C., Collins, C., Hunter, D.J., McCartney, G. and Smith, K.E. (2014) The impact of Thatcherism on health and well-being in Britain. International Journal of Health Services 44 (1): 53–71.
Shildrick, T., MacDonald, R., Webster, C. and Garthwaite, K. (2012) Poverty and Insecurity: Life in Low-Pay, No-Pay Britain. Bristol, UK: Policy Press.
Slater, T. (2014) The myth of ‘Broken Britain’: Welfare reform and the production of ignorance. Antipode 46 (4): 948–969.
Smith, K.E. (2013a) Beyond Evidence Based Policy in Public Health: The Interplay of Ideas. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
Smith, K.E. (2013b) Institutional filters: The translation and re-circulation of ideas about health inequalities within policy. Policy & Politics 41 (1): 81–100.
Smith, K.E. (2010) Research, policy and funding – Academic treadmills and the squeeze on intellectual spaces. The British Journal Of Sociology 61 (1): 176–195.
Smith, K.E. et al (2009) Divergence or convergence? health inequalities & policy in a devolved Britain. Critical Social Policy 29 (2): 216–42.
Smith, K.E. and Kandlik Eltanani, M. (2015) What kinds of policies to reduce health inequalities in the UK do researchers support? Journal of Public Health. 37 (1): 6–17.
Snowdon, C. (2010) The Spirit Level Delusion: Fact-checking the Left’s New Theory of Everything. Washington DC: Democracy Institute / Little Dice.
Springett, J. and Scott-Samuel, A. (2007) Hegemony or health promotion? Prospects for reviving England’s lost discipline. Journal of the Royal Society of Health 127 (5): 211–214.
Stiglitz, J. (2012) Macroeconomic fluctuations, inequality, and human development, Journal of Human Development and Capabilities, 13 (1): 31–58.
Weber, M. (1968) Charismatic authority and its routinization. In: S.N. Eisenstadt (ed.) Max Weber – On Charisma and Institution Building. Chicago, IL and London: The University of Chicago Press, pp. 48–65.
Whitehead, M. (2007) A typology of actions to tackle inequalities in health. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 61: 473–478.
Whitehead, M. and Dahlgren, G. (2007) Concepts and principles for tackling social inequalities in health. Levelling Up (Part 1). Copenhagen: World Health Organization. http://www.euro.who.int/document/e89383.pdf, accessed 2 February 2015.
Wilkinson, R. and Pickett, K. (2009) The Spirit Level: Why More Equal Societies Almost Always do Better. London: Penguin.
Wright, S. (2012) Welfare-to-work, agency and personal responsibility. Journal of Social Policy 41 (2): 309–28.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Scott-Samuel, A., Smith, K. Fantasy paradigms of health inequalities: Utopian thinking?. Soc Theory Health 13, 418–436 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1057/sth.2015.12
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/sth.2015.12